Dissemination of IT for the Promotion of Materials Science (DoITPoMS)

PreviousNext

Summary

Prints have separate resolution in the x-y plane (determined by minimum movement of a printing nozzle/laser) and z direction (determined by layer height). This is then separate from minimum feature size which is determined by diameter of the nozzle/laser point.

To help distinguish the various methods of polymer additive manufacturing, the benefits, limitations and usage of each are summarised in the table below.

Type of AM

Benefits

Downsides

Best for

Material Extrusion (geared towards FDM)

  • Cheap
  • Many materials available
  • Bad quality print
  • Significant anisotropic effects
  • Good chance of warping from heat
  • Amateur use
  • Rapid prototyping


Photopolymerisation

  • High quality prints
  • Isotropic


  • Very limited materials available
  • Lots of post-processing
  • No hollow sections
  • Photosensistive
  • Functional prototyping
  • Moulds

Material Jetting

  • Multiple materials possible at once
  • Good quality prints
  • Very smooth surface finish
  • Very expensive
  • Limited materials
  • Photosensitive
  • Rapid prototyping
  • Coloured, custom models
  • Moulds

Powder Bed Fusion

  • No support structures
  • Mass production easier with MJF
  • Relatively good quality prints
  • Limited post-processing
  • Limited materials available
  • Rough surface finish
  • No hollow sections
  • Chance of warping from heat
  • Functional prototyping
  • Custom end-use models


It is important to note that all additive manufacturing methods struggle to control properties with the precision and variety that traditional methods have. Limited material pool size and printing effects such as the anisotropy in FDM prints prevent additive manufacturing being seen as a better alternative to existing methods. Combined with the fact that additive manufacturing is generally quite slow and unable to produce products in bulk, AM is mostly being used in pre-production for prototyping, to produce parts that are used to make moulds which then allow fast production, and in printing one-off custom objects such as hearing aids (which require specific shapes to fit in the user’s ear).

Looking specifically at FDM, properties are highly anisotropic and can vary greatly depending on variables such as infill percentage, fill pattern used and print direction. How you create a print should be considered when making a product with its purpose in mind so these variables can be chosen appropriately.